Monday, August 9, 2010

4e powers are nice but...

Before the fourth edition of Dungeons & Dragons was released, I was eager to make the change to the new system. I had heard much about how this set of rules was going to simplify things and make it easier and faster to play. For a while after it was released, I tried to love it. But ultimately I abandoned it and sold all my 4e books on eBay.

Nevertheless, I am impressed with the 4e combat system. It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat turn and all the various maneuvers one can make. It is the sum result of decades of house rules and subsequent official implementation of these house rules combined with a new system called "powers."

For my own future D&D campaigns, I am currently assembling a new set of house rules. These rules are a combination of various editions of D&D into a game that focuses on old school sandbox campaign play. Since all of the D&D rules ultimately center around combat, I am choosing to use most of the combat rules presented in 4e.

No doubt grognards will think I'm crazy. How can I have an old school D&D game without THAC0? And what about all those silly powers that homogenizes all of the character classes? Well, I think I can use THAC0 (or something essentially the same as THAC0) within a general 4e combat framework and still call it "old school." But that's a subject of another article.

The use of powers in 4e was a good innovation. It consolidates everything that a character can do in combat under one definition. A basic mêlée attack is a power. Clerics healing the wounded is a power. A fireball spell is a power. The finely polished game mechanic of powers in D&D is a tremendously effective tool when it comes to standardizing and simplifying the complex rule exceptions that built up over the decades since 1974. It's a wonderful hammer for building a better set of rules.

However...

If you only have a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.
— Abraham Maslow

The developers of 4e took the new concept of powers and got carried away with it. They applied it to everything. The result was fighters having a vast array of powers that are comical. All of the classes were reduced to a single, simplified mechanism that created well-defined niches which the developers felt that they had to fill in order to complete the game. The elimination of Vancian magic was a direct result of the overuse of powers in the game's structure. Playing a fighter at the table now seems indistinguishable from spell casters what with all the crazy-named powers such as "Indomitable Battle Strike" and "Strike of the Watchful Guard." Munchkinism has been institutionalized in 4e. The system-wide implementations of powers helped to seal the fate of 4e being essentially World of Warcraft for the tabletop.

The way that powers completely dominate the rules in 4e is not to my liking. Yet, at its core, 4e powers are good system. As I said, it consolidates spells, monster abilities, and combat maneuvers into one polished system. I think that powers make 4e an excellent game system. I just have trouble calling it Dungeons & Dragons.

So in my house rules, I'm using the basic framework of 4e combat and a fraction of the powers system from that edition. Vancian magic will remain but I will redefine all the spells in terms of powers. (And perhaps I'll use the 4e rules for "rituals" but I'm not sure at this point. Probably not.) Some of the 4e racial powers are interesting. Fighters and other martial classes will have few, if any powers at all.

Instead of using the mammoth damage rolls of 4e that contributed to the massive hit point inflation in that edition, I'll use the old damage rolls of 1e. Likewise, hit dice for all the classes and monsters.

OSRIC has a nice way of equating HD to class level so I'll use that for plugging monsters into the 4e-style combat system. Or will I use THAC0? The 4e system of calculating attack rolls is so simple that I might use that instead. More on that subject later.

Will my mutant bastard set of D&D rules be balanced? Of course not. D&D was never completely balanced. That's the nature of the various character classes. The trouble with 4e is that those rules are too balanced. Balanced to the point of making all the classes, in strictly mechanical game rule terms, exactly alike.

41 comments:

Robert said...

Heh. Well, for me, THAC0 isn’t a requirement for “old school” feel. (Indeed, though I knew about it, my group never used THAC0 until it was made the default in 2e.) Rather, the least “old school” thing about the 4e combat system to me is this: “It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat turn and all the various maneuvers one can make.”

If that’s what you want, though, it doesn’t matter whether it is “old school” or not.

Nope said...

Yessir, completely agree. 4e is a tight system, and I love the idea behind powers. I've been doing much of the same as your about to do(mutant hybridized rules), using the structure of 4e, but ignoring the at-will/encounter/daily paradigm of powers. I also canned feats and opportunity attacks, rolling some feats over into class abilities(they become what are essentially powers) It's still rough, but it's getting there. Not really meant to be old school, but is more focused on speed of play.

Xeveninti said...

Robert, the same questions and discussions kept cropping up at game tables again and again for decades. When and how much can characters speak during a combat turn? When do you make saving throws against ongoing effects? What is the move cost to diagonal squares? How does line of sight precisely work? How do bonuses stack? And so on.

OD&D provides basic guidelines. It's been argued that the beauty of old school D&D game play is that the sparse nature of the rules encourages house ruling. This is part of the fun. But there are certain fundamental rule questions that crop up with every edition. I believe that many of the answers to such questions are adequately answered in much of the 4e combat rules.

But not everything about 4e combat is desirable for old school play. That's why I'm attempting to temper it with rules from earlier editions. For instance, I'm probably going to use THAC0/BAB instead of 1/2 level for attacks.

Robert said...

Well, my experience is different. Those questions haven’t come up repeatedly in my groups. I don’t find them fundamental.

I’m not particularly fond of 4e’s answers to most of them either, but that’s a different discussion.

I’ll agree that 4e’s combat system is a nice skirmish wargame. I just don’t find such a thing appropriate to my idea of “old school” RPG style anymore than it was when, e.g., TFT appeared.

Chris Creel said...

Hey, it's good to see you blogging again. You are the guy who introduced me to the rpg blog-o-sphere and thus inspired me to start blogging as well. I wish you well with your writing project too.

windmark8040 said...

Hey, being that I just stumbled into your blog, I am glad that you decided to keep at it!

I myself am constantly nettling, trying to get to a point where I am totally happy with the 'crunch' of various rpg's.

Don't get discouraged!

Eldrad Wolfsbane said...

I posted this in an older post 4E vs Pathfinder. I am re-posting it here as well.

After playing 4th edition since it came out I decided to just stop playing/DMing. The game just stopped being fun. The stupidly large amounts of hit points compared to the small amounts of damage that you dish out just got boring from around 6th level on up. Any role playing game that has combats lasting over 30 minutes is just bad game design. Some large combats lasted over 3 hours! My old gaming group is still playing it without me/wife/daughter and claim that it is now going faster.


A social activity that works better with less people?

I am checking out Pathfinder which seems like an improvement in many ways to 3.5 but I will have to run it to see.

I still can't figure out why someone would design monsters with full character stats.

I am closely looking at the OSR games such as LL and S&W with the S&W complete rules looking really good to me.

Eldrad Wolfsbane said...

SO how did your players in your gaming group take your departure from the 4th edition? None of my gaming group has spoke to me in person since my announcement. I tried to get them to occasionally try something else but the ONLY answer was "I only like 4th edition" even if they had never played anything else so my hand was forced and I had to pull the plug.

Unknown said...

After playing 4th edition since it came out I decided to just stop playing/DMing.

hybrid solar inverter in pakistan


inverters in pakistan

SK Digital Dubai UAE said...

The developers of 4e took the new concept of powers and got carried away with it.
that's amazing for me.

best seo experts in dallas

SK Digital Dubai UAE said...

I'll see where it goes.

dallas seo consultant
wordpress developer dallas
dallas wordpress developer

Shopnroar said...

You are beautiful, you made me believe that this world is worth living in.
online shopping engine
best price online shopping

Pack Techseal said...

The Battle for the Mid-Realm, which you can see here on BGG.

packing tape manufacturers in pakistan
adhesive tapes manufacturers in lahore
4m brand in pakistan
4m brand tapes in pakistan
power brand tapes in pakistan
Adhesive tapes in pakistan
packing tapes in pakistan
water based tape in pakistan
gum paper printed tape in pakistan
pvc tape manufacturers in pakistan
Masking Tape Suppliers in pakistan
adhesive tapes Wholesalers in Pakistan
scotch tape supplier in pakistan
scotch tape manufacturer in pakistan
duct tape manufacturer in pakistan
duct tapes in pakistan

future Tech Soul said...

thanks for sharing this post
online auction and bidding system
bids on jobs
bids on used stuff

online auction and bidding system said...

I visit your blogs these are amazing and I really want more blogs from you.
online auction and bidding system
bids on jobs

ChoiceGenie said...

SO however did your players in your play cluster take your departure from the fourth edition? None of my play cluster has spoke to ME head to head since my announcement. i attempted to urge them to {sometimes|to often} attempt one thing else however solely|the sole} answer was "I only like fourth edition" albeit they'd ne'er vie anything so my hand was forced and that i had to tug the plug
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Power to choose
Texas Electric Company
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates

Unknown said...

The use of powers in 4e was a good innovation. It consolidates everything that a character can do in combat under one definition.!!!
@Compare Electric Rates-|@Compare Electric Plans-|@Texas Electric Company-|@Texas Electric Rates-
Texas Electric Company

Compare Electric Rates

Texas Electric Rates

Power to Choose

Compare Electric Plans

ChoiceGenie said...

I'm using the basic framework of 4e combat and a fraction of the powers system from that edition
Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Power to choose
Texas Electric Company
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates

Compare Electric Rates said...

I abandoned it and sold all my 4e books on eBay.!!!
Compare electric rates USA
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Best electric providers Texas

SHOPnROAR said...

Love myself I do.
Online Shopping Engine
Price Comparison Engine
Best Price Online Shopping Engine
Best Price Online Shopping
Online Store
Comparison Shopping Engine
online shopping price compare
online shopping best price
shopping engine
price compare online shopping

Compare Electric Rates said...

It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat turn and all the various maneuvers one can make. It is the sum result of decades of house rules and subsequent official implementation of these house rules combined with a new system called "powers."
Compare electric rates USA
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Best electric providers Texas

Compare Electric Rates said...

If you only have a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.
Compare Electric Rates
Compare electric rates Texas
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare electric TX
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Rates
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose commercial
Commercial Electric Plans Texas

Compare Electric Rates said...

I'll use the old damage rolls of 1e. Likewise, hit dice for all the classes and monsters.
Compare Electric Rates
Compare electric rates Texas
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare electric TX
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Rates
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose commercial
Commercial Electric Plans Texas

ChoiceGenie said...

my own future D&D campaigns, I am currently assembling a new set of house rules. Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial elecric plans Texas
Texas Electric Company
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose Commercial
Power to choose commercial
Compare electric rates Texas
Texas Electric Choice

ChoiceGenie said...

How can I have an old school D&D game without THAC0 Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial elecric plans Texas
Texas Electric Company
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose Commercial
Power to choose commercial
Compare electric rates Texas
Texas Electric Choice

ChoiceGenie said...

I am impressed with the 4e combat system. It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat Compare Electric Plans
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare Electric Plans
Commercial elecric plans Texas
Texas Electric Company
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose Commercial
Power to choose commercial
Compare electric rates Texas
Texas Electric Choice

Compare Electric Rates said...

I am impressed with the 4e combat system. It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat turn and all the various maneuvers one can make.
Compare Electric Rates
Compare electric rates Texas
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare electric TX
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Rates
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose commercial
Commercial Electric Plans Texas

Compare Electric Rates said...

If you only have a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail.
— Abraham Maslow
Compare Electric Rates
Compare electric rates Texas
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare electric TX
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Rates
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose commercial
Commercial Electric Plans Texas

Shopnroar said...


Price Comparison Shopping Engine
Price Comparison Engine
Comparison Engine
Price Comparison Shopping Website
Price Comparison Website

Compare Electric Rates said...

Nevertheless, I am impressed with the 4e combat system. It rigidly defines the sequence of the combat turn and all the various maneuvers one can make. It is the sum result of decades of house rules and subsequent official implementation of these house rules combined with a new system called "powers."

Compare Electric Rates
Compare electric rates Texas
Commercial Texas electric rates
Compare electric TX
Compare Electric Rates
Texas Electric Rates
Texas Electric Company
Power to Choose
Compare Electric Plans
Texas Electric Choice
Compare Electric Rates
Commercial Electric Rates Texas
Compare electric plans Texas
Power to choose commercial
Commercial Electric Plans Texas

Compare Electric Rates said...

The use of powers in 4e was a good innovation. It consolidates everything that a character can do in combat under one definition.
Power to Choose

Power to Choose

Shopnroar said...


Its a Good Feature!
Price Comparison Shopping Engine
Comparative Shopping
Comparison Engine
Comparative Shopping
Price Comparison Shopping Website
Price Comparison Website
Comparative Shoppingn USA

Shopnroar said...

The Great Working
Price Comparison Shopping Engine
Comparative Shopping
Comparison Engine
Comparative Shopping
Price Comparison Shopping Website
Price Comparison Website
Comparative Shoppingn USA

Web Easy said...

good piece of work....

SEO services pakistan
seo agency pakistan
seo provider pakistan
seo packages pakistan
Digital Marketing Agency Pakistan
Web Development Company

Web Easy said...

online quran
A digital platform of online quran has been provided by the Pak Company.Everyone can enjoy of these services all they require is a computer and internet connection.
There are 9 benefits of reciting Quran

Purification of heart
Be best from the people
Recitation of each letter from Quran get Ten Rewards
Understanding matters Of daily life
Intercession judgement day
Opportunity of communication with Allah
Get place in Heaven on the basis of Quran memorization
Quran ll lead to Heaven
Completion of religious obligation

best islamic books
quran translation in urdu
online quran
islamic books center
Pak Company

Plagiarism checker free said...

Plagiarism checker free

Plagiarism checker online

Plagiarism detector free

Paragraph Rewriter

keyword position checker

Seo Tool Serp

Unknown said...

our site, everything is sorted. best buy coupon bing ads coupon codeflights to Cuba

Web Easy said...

WebEasy is a leading Web Development Company in Pakistan.We are Providing our Digital Services on Fiverr as well.
Professional Responsive Wordpress Website, Dynamic Web Application For Your Business , Modern Business Logo and
Complete Seo Of Your Site For 1st Page Ranking On Google are the services providing by WebEasy.

Our Services on Fiverr:
I Will Create A Professional Responsive Wordpress Website
I Will Create Dynamic Web Application For Your Business
I Will Do A Modern Business Logo
I Will Do Complete Seo Of Your Site For 1st Page Ranking On Google
Visit our Portfolio:
WebEasy Portfolio

unknown said...

Hair Zone is a recommended place for Hair Transplant in Lahore on the basis of experience, best results and Hair Transplant Price.We have all the latest techniques of transplants. Our staff is Hair Specialist Lahore. We are offering affordable Hair Transplant Cost in Lahore.
Fue Transplant cost in Lahore
Fue Transplant cost in Lahore
best hair transplant in lahore
hair transplant in pakistan lahore cost
hair wig in lahore
hair replacement lahore
hair replacement in lahore
hair replacement in lahore
Hair Transplant in Lahore
best hair transplant
Hair Specialist Lahore
hair unit price in lahore
hair transplant lahore
Hair Transplant Price
Hair Transplant Cost Lahore
hair transplant price in lahore
prp treatment price
fue hair transplant price
Hair Transplant in Lahore
best hair transplant
best hair transplant surgeon in lahore
non surgical hair unit
hair transplant clinc in lahore
best hair transplant
top 10 hair transplant surgeons in pakistan
good school in iqbal town
best school in mustafa town
good school in mustafa town
holy quran
quran pak
quran pak online shopping
holy quran online
online holy quran
online shopping quran pak
quran pak online
holy quran with translation

Unknown said...

There are many problems encountered by residents while living in a house which depicts that the house needs immediate care. Suppose the residents of your house are developing allergic reactions which makes our safe space at home a little hard to live. Home is a place where a person comes after a tiring day but what if he is not getting peace at his own place, what should he do then? A professional home inspection in gaithersburg md is always needed in order to make sure that the house where we are living is safe from all the toxins that may affect our health and all other factors that could cause damage to our property which was built with love and a huge amount of our savings. If you suspect something is present in your house causing your family to develop allergic reactions like stuffiness of nose or sneezing, coughing etc, call top to bottom services today and we will make sure to provide you a thorough home mold inspection in gaithersburg md in order to be sure if this is the problem that has been affecting you or there is something more grave present inside your house that needs immediate attention.

Unknown said...

Mold Inspection Sciences of Houston is a professional mold inspection, mold detection, and mold testing company. We are the premier Mold Inspection Houston Our inspectors are certified residential thermographs, and are equipped with infrared thermal imaging cameras to better complete your home mold inspection Mold testing Houston Our inspectors are certified residential thermographs and are equipped with infrared thermal imaging cameras to better complete your home mold inspection Mold Inspection Houston TX